74 art Reviews with Responses

Substance Substance

Rated 5 / 5 stars

is this pizzagate

JackDCurleo responds:

This is a far deeper dish than #pizzagate


Rated 2 / 5 stars

Hey lad. I appreciate the coloring here but what you did is against the portal rules. (Something about submitting 'doll' recolors. This would fit into that category.)

Please remove it.

SoundBounce responds:

Yeh no problem. Do you mind elaborating on what a 'doll' recolor is though?

Rotk├Ąppchen Redux Rotk├Ąppchen Redux

Rated 5 / 5 stars

ayy yo I really love her hairstyle. Face triggers my autism tho

JackDCurleo responds:

Haha, faces are hard to get right with watercolor, one of these days I'll make it happen!

Power girl Blow Power girl Blow

Rated 0 / 5 stars


Avaloniromman responds:


Oh, Merlo~ Oh, Merlo~

Rated 2.5 / 5 stars

head is really big and wierd

People find this review helpful!
BluMiu responds:

You think so? I was having a bit of trouble with over the shoulder, so something could have not been scaled

Cutie Cutie

Rated 5 / 5 stars

I really like this. I'm sorry I can't say more.

Marklikeart responds:


Legend of skyrift preview 7 Legend of skyrift preview 7

Rated 2.5 / 5 stars

Right. So the artwork is alright. There's some things wrong with some of the details in the background.

I'd rather critique this from a writing and overall design standpoint. I know comics and books are something vastly different, but it doesn't excuse Mary-Sue characters and mediocre dialogue. The dialogue falls flat on it's face. and the woman screams Mary-Sue.

We'll call her princess Booblarge. So, when princess Booblarge suddenly changes her mind without any form of reasoning or depiction of an event that changes her mind, it raises a red flag for me. So too does the guy, who we'll call Dr. Manboy, with his swooning. I'm sure you could dismiss this as 'an anime thing' where storyline is botched for style over actual plot. But, like, no. Don't say that. I've seen good anime with good writing and good plots. Stop. No.

So right. Nothing would be better than you going out of your way to choreograph some sort of event that changes her mind. But if that's not plausible, something as simple as Manboy giving Booblarge a particular reason to let him follow her would work well enough. Maybe she wants to keep him around to eat his delicious blood and soul. Perhaps he has some sort of magical key, such as a surgeon in his family that can grant her breast reduction surgery at a discount. Maybe she's short on funds and he's dumb enough to give her his life savings to take him with her <i>Maybe she just likes him because he is cute to her.</i>

I would seriously prefer that.

I'm no color expert. In fact it's my weakest suit. But therein lies the problem: if I can spot it it's dead wrong. Your characters have much higher contrast than the background and I can't stop noticing how much I hate that.

BELLUMART responds:

I honestly stopped reading within the first few sentences, tl;dr. I'm just going receive this critique off the star rating.

Future issues will be more refined, so maybe we'll see a higher star rating later on.

Thanks for the feed back!

Making the Rounds Making the Rounds

Rated 5 / 5 stars

Tina looking fabulous AF


People find this review helpful!
JackDCurleo responds:

Thanks, buddy. Tina thrives in the madness of the modern era

Naked Lunch Naked Lunch

Rated 5 / 5 stars

What an interesting sounding book. It is a collection of short stories or something?

ApocalypseCartoons responds:

Sorta. More like a bunch of heroin-induced nightmares.

Raven Butt Sniff Raven Butt Sniff

Rated 0 / 5 stars

really cool you know what would be even cooler if she farted in his face and the pink man came out and said 'got'eeem'

that would be a funny meme

bxBLAZExd responds: